This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you click a link and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
You can make bagels less chewy by adjusting your technique, ingredients, and cooking times.
If you’ve been struggling with bagels that feel like rubber bands, you’re not alone, and the good news is that the fix is totally doable at home.
The chewiness in bagels comes from high-gluten flour, a long fermentation, and that signature boiling step, but you can dial all of that back to get a softer, more tender bite.
In this post, we’ll break down exactly how to make bagels less chewy, covering dough hydration, flour choices, boiling time, and even baking temperature so you can finally enjoy a gentler, fluffier bagel.
Let’s dig into the best ways to soften your homemade bagels without losing that classic shape.
Why Bagels Turn Out Chewy and How to Make Bagels Less Chewy
To really understand how to make bagels less chewy, you first need to see why they get so tough in the first place.
Bagels are supposed to have some bite, but when they cross into jaw-tiring territory, it’s usually because of a few specific choices in the process.
The good news is that every one of these causes has a simple fix, and once you know them, you’ll be able to tweak any recipe to suit your preference.
Let’s explore the main reasons and the direct solutions for each one.
1. Switch to a Lower Protein Flour
The biggest culprit behind chewy bagels is the type of flour you’re using.
Most bagel recipes call for bread flour or even high-gluten flour because that builds the dense, chewy structure people expect from a New York-style bagel.
But if you want to know how to make bagels less chewy, the easiest swap is to use all-purpose flour instead.
All-purpose flour has less protein (around 10-11%) compared to bread flour (12-14%), which means it forms less gluten.
Less gluten directly translates to a softer, more tender crumb, so this one change can make a massive difference.
You can even mix half bread flour and half all-purpose flour to keep a little structure while still reducing chewiness.
Another trick is to replace a portion of the flour with cake flour or even some instant mashed potato flakes, which interrupt gluten formation and add softness.
By lowering the protein content, you’re actively fighting the very thing that makes bagels chewy.
2. Increase the Hydration in Your Dough
A drier dough creates a denser, chewier bagel because the gluten strands are tighter and more compact.
To make bagels less chewy, you’ll want to add more water to your dough than traditional recipes suggest.
Most classic bagel dough has around 50-55% hydration (meaning 50-55 grams of water per 100 grams of flour).
If you bump that up to 60-65%, your dough will be softer and more extensible, which leads to a lighter, airier interior after baking.
A wetter dough is stickier and harder to shape, but the payoff is a much more tender bite.
You can also add a small amount of fat, like olive oil or butter, to your dough.
Fat coats the gluten strands and prevents them from bonding too tightly, which is another effective way to reduce chewiness.
Just remember that a softer dough needs a gentler hand during shaping, but your reward will be a bagel that’s pleasantly soft on the inside.
3. Shorten the Boiling Time
The boiling step is what gives bagels their shiny crust and chewy exterior, so cutting it down is a direct answer to how to make bagels less chewy.
When you boil a bagel, the hot water sets the outer layer of starch, and the longer you boil, the thicker and tougher that crust becomes.
Traditional bagels are boiled for 1-2 minutes per side, which produces that classic dense chew.
If you reduce your boiling time to just 30-45 seconds per side, you’ll get a much thinner crust and a softer bite overall.
Even better, you can skip the boiling entirely and just spray the shaped bagels with water before baking.
This method, sometimes called a “steam bake,” still gives you a nice shine but without the chewy casing that boiling creates.
By shortening the boil or skipping it, you’ll immediately notice a softer outer layer, and the inside will stay fluffier too.
4. Reduce Fermentation Time
Long fermentation is another reason bagels become chewy, because the extended proofing time develops more gluten and flavor.
When you let your dough rise for 12-24 hours in the fridge, the enzymes break down starches and tighten the protein network.
If you want to make bagels less chewy, try using a shorter, warmer rise instead.
A single rise of 1-2 hours at room temperature will produce a tender, soft bagel that’s still flavorful.
You can also cut back on the kneading time, since over-kneading develops excessive gluten.
Stop kneading just when the dough comes together into a smooth ball, even if it’s a bit tacky.
By reducing fermentation and kneading, you allow the dough to stay relaxed, which means the final bagel will be far less tough.
5. Bake at a Lower Temperature
High heat is great for a crispy, crackly crust, but it also firms up the entire bagel quickly.
To make bagels less chewy, lower your oven temperature and bake them a bit longer.
Most recipes call for 425°F to 450°F (220°C to 230°C), which sets the crust fast and can make the whole bagel denser.
Dropping the temperature to 375°F (190°C) allows the inside to cook through more gently while the crust stays thinner and softer.
You’ll also want to remove the bagels from the oven as soon as they’re lightly golden, not dark brown.
Overbaking dries out the crumb and turns it chewy, so pull them out the moment they look set.
A shorter bake at a lower heat is one of the most reliable ways to get a tender result.
Other Simple Tricks to Soften Your Bagels
Beyond the core changes, there are a few extra hacks you can use to make bagels less chewy without overhauling your whole process.
These are easy additions that boost softness and improve the overall texture.
Add Dough Conditioners Like Milk or Honey
Replacing some of the water with milk adds fat and lactose, which tenderize the crumb.
Honey or sugar also interfere with gluten development, and they help retain moisture in the baked bagel.
Just a tablespoon of honey or a splash of milk can soften the final texture noticeably.
Use a Tangzhong Method
The tangzhong technique involves cooking a small portion of flour with water into a paste before adding it to the dough.
This gelatinizes the starch, which holds onto moisture and prevents the gluten from being too elastic.
It’s a bakery secret that makes breads and bagels incredibly soft, so it’s perfect if you’re serious about reducing chewiness.
Steam Your Oven
Placing a pan of boiling water at the bottom of your oven creates steam during the first few minutes of baking.
Steam keeps the surface moist and delays crust setting, which gives the bagel more time to expand and stay tender.
It’s a simple, low-effort trick that makes a big difference in softness.
So, How to Make Bagels Less Chewy?
You can make bagels less chewy by using lower-protein flour, increasing hydration, shortening the boil, reducing fermentation, and baking at a lower temperature.
These five changes target the exact factors that create that dense, rubbery texture.
Start with just one or two tweaks, like switching to all-purpose flour and boiling for less time, and you’ll see a huge difference.
Remember that bagels will always have a little bite, which is part of their charm, but you can absolutely control how much chew is in the final product.
Whether you prefer a soft sandwich bagel or a breakfast treat that’s easy on the jaw, these tips will get you there.
So go ahead, try this method for how to make bagels less chewy, and enjoy a tender, fluffy bagel that still tastes like the real deal.